Footwear is not just an accessory – for many, it’s a way to express themselves, their values and personality. In the footwear industry and even in wider fashion conversations, an interesting debate is becoming more popular. In this day and age, should society prioritise ethical considerations over style? As the rise of vegan leather signifies a shift in consumer values, we delve deeper into the pros and cons of each stance.
What Is Vegan Leather?
Vegan leather has been growing in popularity, especially for accessories such as bags, belts and boots, often derived from polyurethane, and when manufactured in innovative ways, it provides a very realistic appearance that is convincing of traditional leather. Vegan leather can even be created using materials like apple peels, pineapple leaves, cork, or recycled plastic – these more experimental methods are also growing in popularity, but are yet to really break into the mainstream of fashion. The general increase in demand suggests a growing appreciation for cruelty-free alternatives but also an innovative approach to sustainable fashion materials.
That being said, traditional leather is certainly still selling well today and it continues to be in high-demand. That’s why we are here to explore some of the differences between the two materials, and to ponder on the future of leather in general.
Pros of Ethical Considerations:
Animal Welfare:
Vegan leather offers a cruelty-free alternative, ensuring no animals are harmed in its production.
Environmental Impact:
Some vegan leathers, especially those sourced from recycled materials, may have a lower carbon footprint than traditional leather.
Innovation in Fashion:
The search for ethical alternatives drives innovation in material science, leading to new, exciting textures and styles.
Pros of Style Considerations:
Durability:
Traditional leather is often revered for its long-lasting nature.
Aesthetic & Feel:
Many find the texture, sheen, and feel of genuine leather unparalleled.
Historical Significance:
Traditional materials have cultural and historical significance in fashion, marking timeless classics.
Historical Context of Leather
Leather has been intertwined with human civilization for millennia. Its origins trace back to prehistoric times when ancient humans utilised animal hides for protection against the elements. These hides, once cured, provided warmth and durability that early fabrics could not.
As civilizations advanced, so did the techniques for leather treatment. In the Middle Ages, the process of tanning leather became more refined, and the material became synonymous with durability and quality. Different regions became renowned for their leather goods, from the thick sole leather of Cordoba to the fine glove leathers of France.
The Industrial Revolution brought machinery that increased production speeds and introduced newer methods of leather processing. This, in turn, allowed leather goods to be more accessible to the masses, cementing leather’s status not just as a utility but as a symbol of style and luxury.
Today, leather remains a staple in fashion, representing both tradition and luxury. However, with growing awareness of ethical and environmental questions, alternatives like vegan leather are emerging to provide choices for the modern consumer.
Now it’s common for brands to offer both traditional and vegan leather, as they understand that consumers like to have this choice themselves, rather than a brand deciding for them. For example, see the vegan range by Blundstone, the famous Chelsea boot company who are well-known for their hard wearing footwear, made of real leather. This just goes to show how influential new materials are on the market.
Caring for Leather Boots (Traditional & Vegan)
To ensure the longevity and maintain the appearance of both traditional leather and vegan leather products, proper care is essential. Here’s a general guide on how to care for each:
For Traditional Leather:
Brushing Off Dirt:
Initiate cleaning by gently brushing off accumulated dirt with a soft brush. For stubborn spots, a slightly damp cloth can be of aid. Excess moisture, however, might harm the leather.
Drying Process:
Post-cleaning, position your boots in an airy location away from direct sun and heating appliances to avoid leather dehydration.
Conditioning:
Before applying any leather maintenance product, it’s wise to test on a less visible part of the boot. Once deemed safe, use a clean cloth or brush, apply the product in a circular motion, and then wipe off the excess.
For Vegan Leather:
Simple Cleanup:
A damp cloth effectively cleans these boots. Swipe gently to avoid material damage.
Drying Technique:
Like their leather counterparts, vegan boots should be air-dried away from intense heat or sunlight.
Footbed Maintenance:
If your boots feature a detachable footbed, it’s advisable to wash it separately with a gentle soap, followed by air-drying it in a flat position.
Choosing Between Traditional & Vegan Leather
For some, the allure of traditional leather lies in its rich history and durability. Its timeless nature has cemented its place in the wardrobes of many. On the other hand, the emergence of vegan leather and other sustainable materials showcases a society increasingly attuned to its ethical footprint.
We have established that it’s not only about appearance, or even just morals. There are some fair points when it comes to wearing traditional leather, a big one being durability. The question of ethics does come into play, but remember that different cultures and individuals have a unique set of values and morals due to the many factors in life, this is ultimately a personal decision. Either way, we’ve learned that it’s not only about how something looks, there’s a lot more to consider when it comes to shopping.
So it’s evident that both ethical considerations and style have their merits. As with most aspects of fashion, the decision often boils down to personal preference and values. The beauty of the modern fashion world is its diversity, offering choices that range from contemporary and innovative to timeless and traditional.
Choosing Your Boots
When it’s time to select boots, your unique style should take centre stage. Whether you opt for vegan or traditional leather, ensure your choice resonates with your personal aesthetic and meshes well with your existing wardrobe. This way, your boots will effortlessly enhance any outfit they accompany.
As the fashion industry evolves, it gifts consumers with a myriad of choices. From vegan boots symbolising innovation and ethics to classic Chelsea boots embodying tradition and timelessness, there’s something for everyone. Ultimately, the choice between ethics and style is personal. And that’s the essence of fashion: a canvas for individual expression, where every choice is valid. Whether one leans towards the contemporary or the classic, it’s a testament to the rich tapestry of options available in the fashion world.
